Question 3 presented students with an excerpt from the essay on being a cripple, part of nancy mairs s collection plaintext. In the title of her essay, mairs immediately breaks one of these rules, referring to herself as a cripple. A rhetorical analysis of disability, an article by nancy mairs. In nancy maris disability, she confronts the mentality that a disabled person is limited and that they are different. Nancy mairs, on being a cripple first, the matter of semantics. Critical analysis of disability by nancy mairs priscilla farah may 11, 2012 author of disability nancy mairs whos a feminist and a cripple, has accomplished a lot in writing and teaching. In this piece, nancy mairs describes her multiple sclerosis and her resulting disability as an integral piece of her identity. Her use of ethos, logos, rhetorical questions, diction, and tone are strong and hardhitting. Analysis of on being a cripple by nancy mairs essay. In her essay, she shamelessly describes herself as a cripple and prefers to use that word over handicapped or disabled. Nancy mair is happy to be addressed as crippled instead of other names that find place in the area of philanthropy to describe her condition. She will choose a word that represents her reality, and if it makes people wince, perhaps i want them to wince. Nancy mairs disability a forty three year old woman has multiple sclerosis and she can barely walk with a brace and a cane. Nancy presents a strong and personal argument towards the positives and negatives of being a cripple.
Nancy mairs, who wrote about her mental illness and. Nancy mairs author of disability a selfclaimed radical feminist and cripple with many accomplishments and degrees under her belt, nancy is known to speak the unspeakable in her poetry, memoirs and essays, especially in disability which was first published in the new york times in 1987. Paircoil2 submit sequences to paircoil2 view supplementary data download paircoil2. I was thinking hard in one of the stalls of the womens room in my office building, as i was shoving my shirt into my jeans and tugging up my zipper. Louise bogan the other day i was thinking of writing an essay on being a cripple. She presents herself as strong empowered by again, being very. A disease that affects the autoimmune system, ms erodes. Nancy mairs is the author of the controversial essay on being a cripple. Analysis of on being a cripple by nancy mairs essay 524 words. In the essay, on being a cripple, mairs writes for readers, disabled or not, about what its like to be crippled. On being a cripple by nancy mairs to escape is nothing. In this superbly written essay, nancy mairs, a feminist writer who has multiple sclerosis, defines the terms in which she will interact with the world.
Peoplecrippled or notwince at the word cripple, as they do not at handicapped or disabled. Analysis of on being a cripple by nancy mairs free. Nancy mairs, who wrote about her mental illness and multiple. Jun 18, 2016 in on being a cripple, nancy mairs satirically talks about the english language and american society while including her life struggle with multiple sclerosis ms. Here, she writes of her experiences dealing with the degenerative disease, multiple sclerosis, on a daily basis as well as her preferences on the proper terms are for what to call a person who is disabilities. The speaker is nancy mairs, an advocate for helping people understand different disabilities. The passage begins i am a cripple and goes on to discuss mairs s. I made the choice a number of years ago, without thinking, unaware of. An acclaimed personal essayist, mairs writes with candor. Rhetorical analysis essay on being a cripple is an essay written by nancy mairs about the experience of living as a cripple.
In on being a cripple, nancy mairs satirically talks about the. Born in long beach, california, in 1943, mairs grew up. Mairs rhetorical analysis sample essays chief reader. In the essay, on being a cripple, nancy mairs describes her thoughts and opinions regarding the illness that she lives with, multiple sclerosis, or ms, as she refers to it. Multiple sclerosis ms is an inflammatory disease that damages the nerve cells and makes it difficult for parts of the nervous system to communicate with one another. Nancy mairs uses vivid imagery in order to paint a stark portrait of the challenges faced with being disabled.
She saw another woman with ms in a show who wants to go to kenya and live a happy life. In disability, writer nancy mairs discusses the experience of being a disabled person in a world focused on the ablebodied. Mairs strongly feels that she has not lost anything in the course of this calamitous. I was thinking hard in one of the stalls of the womens room in my office building, as i was shoving my shirt into my. Nancy mairs so rewarding for so many years, and to lisa johnson.
Some of the struggles that mairs faces is the fear of being a burden to those she loves. What if people waited before judging and they were in their shoes for a day. In this superbly written essay, nancy mairs, a feminist writer who has multiple sclerosis, defines the terms in which she will interact with the. Further into the essay, students come to appreciate mairs s humor as well as her seriousness. Mairs was a budding poet in her late 20s, suffering from agoraphobia and depression she had once attempted suicide when she was told that she had m. Being handicapped or disables isnt always the best lifestyle to have, but it isnt up to you on what gifts you get. We currently live in a time of intense political correctness. She brings her world to us by discussing a wide variety of things including language, family, and humor, and how these.
She makes her points clear and her dry humor entertains but makes the reader. Sep 03, 2015 nancy mairs uses this piece as an informational yet opinionated piece talking about her disability. Nancy mairs, who has multiple sclerosis, is very aware of her condition and her limitations. Nov 25, 2012 the descriptive essay, on being a cripple, by nancy mairs demonstrates a purpose to postulate the way society has brainwashed people to judge others incorrectly in order to expose the true thoughts of a person living beneath the glamorized world. On being a cripple, by nancy mairs, sheds light on the authors everyday struggle to cope with her degenerative form of multiple sclerosis. See the article in its original context from july 9, 1987, section c, page 2 buy reprints. Analysis of disability by nancy mairs essay 1019 words.
The stories that caught my eye and analyzed were on being a cripple by nancy mairs and the second one was on. I line made the choice a number of years ago, without 5 thinking, unaware of my motives for doing so. Nancy mairs was born in long beach, california in 1943 and raised in massachusetts, near boston. On being a cripple center for civic reflection community. Urioj l en pdf regulation eu no of the room and board. Word download a pdf of the an analysis of on being a cripple student. Nancy mairs on being a cripple essay new york jossey cripple a on mairs nancy. A great writer on disability, physicality, sex, pain, meaning, and more has passed away. In on being a cripple by nancy mairs and living under circes spell by matthew soyster, the reader is lead into the state of mind of people living with disabilities. In her piece on being a cripple, mairs relays to her audience how she accepts being crippled, and she brings attention to her interpretation of the language used by society. The descriptive essay, on being a cripple, by nancy mairs demonstrates a purpose to postulate the way society has brainwashed people to judge others incorrectly in order to expose the true thoughts of a person living beneath the glamorized world. I choose from among several possibilities, the most common of which are. Nancy mairs, who is physically impaired with multiple sclerosis, chooses the word cripple to describe herself. She was born nancy pedrick smith on july 23, 1943, in long beach, calif.
Author of disability nancy mairs whos a feminist and a cripple, has accomplished a lot in writing and teaching. While describing her triumphs she consistently is able to find the light at the end of the tunnel or silver lining which makes her case worth living. Rhetorical analysis of being a cripple essay 752 words. Nancy mairs uses this piece as an informational yet opinionated piece talking about her disability. Her remarkable personality shows in many of her essays especially in disability which was first published in 1987 in the new york times. For negatives, nancy describes that she has selfloathing and extra compensation due to being a cripple. A respond to the article on being a cripple by nancy mairs. Mairs strongly feels that she has not lost anything in the course of this calamitous disease 37, known as multiple sclerosis, a. On being a cripple nancy mairs posted by aplogosblog on january 27, 2017 may 9, 2017 intention. Analysis of disability by nancy mairs 1019 words 5 pages. Jan 27, 2017 on being a cripple nancy mairs posted by aplogosblog on january 27, 2017 may 9, 2017 intention.
She will choose a word that represents her reality. She blatantly chooses the word cripple in describing herself not so as to seem crude and bitter, but as she puts it, to be accurate and to better describe the truth of her existence. Mairs describes her condition as crippled, parts of her body incapacitated due to degeneration from multiple sclerosis. She explains that while she wasnt born the disease she was diagnosed in. Analysis of on being a cripple by nancy mairs free essays. The passage begins i am a cripple and goes on to discuss mairss. Multiple sclerosis is a chronic degenerative disease of the central nervous system, in which the myelin that sheathes the nerves is somehow eaten away and sear tissue forms in its place, interrupting the nerves signals. When it comes to homeless or people who have a disability they are quickly to be judge by others. Analysis of nancy mairs s on being a cripple 1187 words 5 pages.
She begins by talking about her life and why she refers to herself as crippled. Her poetry, memoirs, and essays deal with many sensitive subjects, including her struggles with the debilitating disease of multiple sclerosis. Mairs was born on july 23, 1943 in long beach, california. Mairs was born on july 23, 1943 in long beach, california she was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis ms when she was 28, and began using a wheelchair soon after. Even now, im not sure what those motives are, but i recog nize that they are complex and not entirely flattering. They find nancy mairs to be a tough customer indeed. What is the meaning of louise bogans quote that precedes the essay. Through its prohibition on birth control, the church has suggested that the only right way to have children is through biological reproduction. Please watch this video teaching sensitive material is tough. Today, students are reading a personal essay by nancy mairs who explains how she identifies. Mairs rhetorical analysis sample essays chief reader commentary. Question 3 presented students with an excerpt from the essay on being a cripple, part of nancy mairss collection plaintext.
The authors purpose in writing this essay was to show the changes a normal functioning person, and their life, go. Analysis of disability by nancy mairs 1008 words bartleby. Analysis of disability by nancy mairs essay medicine and. Nov 04, 20 nancy presents a strong and personal argument towards the positives and negatives of being a cripple. By continuing well assume youre on board with our cookie policy. We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. On being a cripple, nancy mairs in her essay on being a cripple, nancy mairs presents her audience with an honest inside view of her life and perspective as a cripple, a word she openly uses to define herself. The author was changed for the better when she became disabled. An excerpt of the text was also used on the ap language and composition test and has been released on the collegeboard website. An acclaimed personal essayist, mairs writes with candor and humor about her experiences as a woman, a wife and mother, a student and teacher, an unconventional catholic and a selfdescribed cripple. She wrote several essays on her experiences as a selfdescribed cripple, including on being a cripple, sex and the gimpy girl, and the memoir waist high in the world. She was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis ms when she was 28, and began using a wheelchair soon after.
Oct 12, 2009 in the essay, on being a cripple, nancy mairs describes her thoughts and opinions regarding the illness that she lives with, multiple sclerosis, or ms, as she refers to it. To read plaintext is like doing some high, hard mountainclimbing with a fearless and experienced guide. She almost did it, made up to the taxi but no escape to kenya for the cripple. She begins by talking about her life and why she refers to herself as. Mairs does because she has grown weary of people treating her with sympathy just because she has a disease. On being a cripple essay example topics, sample papers. Nancy mairs knows a lot about that, because she is crippled. Mairs believes that crippled is a more proper definition for her condition than other. This question counts onethird of the total essay section score. Mairs wrote, on being a cripple nancy in 1986, although it still very much applies today. She brings her world to us by discussing a wide variety of things including language, family, and humor, and how these all relate to her life.
Nancy mairs s unacceptant, insistent reexamination and reevaluation of self, language, and ideasa central strategy of feminist thoughtbrings the reader through a. Share nancy mairs quotations about children, writing and birth. On being cripple is an essay written by nancy mairs, who has been afflicted with the multiple sclerosis. Write a respond essay to the article on being a cripple by nancy mairs introduction. People crippled or notwince at the word cripple, as they do not.
Then write an essay in which you analyze how mairs presents herself in this passage. This student essay consists of approximately 2 pages of analysis of an analysis of on being a cripple. Nancy mairs, now 70 years old, was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis at the age of 28. In the following passage nancy mairs, who has multiple sclerosis, calls herself a cripple. She is sure in her use of the word cripple to identify herself and that shows a certain strength. For positives, mairs tells about the gentleness and knowledge that comes from being an ms patient. Pdf rhetorical analysis of nancy mairs cripple essay ava. Nancy mairs, on being a cripple is a text in 50 essays. Mairs discusses her struggles with her disability and how she takes steps to cope with it by showing her dominance. She wrote this essay to express her thoughts on having ms and how she is learning to accept herself and her disease. Nancy mairs, whose encounters with mental illness, disease and religious faith found expression in a series of trenchant, intensely personal essays and memoirs, died on saturday at her home in tucson. On being a cripple nancy mairs essay pdf on being a cripple by nancy mairs note from the mod i wanted to share an essay that has always meant a great deal to me, but i see its only available in.
502 120 692 1158 1561 433 533 670 948 1146 1183 603 1486 1214 789 999 203 604 819 1019 314 1187 1383 359 112 728 715 195 227 821 398 130 1289 945 985